Fragrance comparison

Good Girl vs Vanilla | 28

Neutral side-by-side notes, performance and similarity. This is not a community vote.

Good Girl
Good Girl Carolina Herrera
Vanilla | 28
Vanilla | 28 Kayali
Different audience

Overview

Rating
0.0
0.0
Year
2016 2018
Concentration
EDP EDP
Gender
Women Unisex
Best For
Date Night, Special Event, Formal Date Night, Special Event, Formal
Season
Cold Cold
Time of day
Night Night

Performance

Longevity
Long-lasting Est.
Long-lasting Est.
Projection
Moderate Est.
Strong Est.
Sillage
Noticeable Est.
Heavy Est.

Est. Estimated from notes and accords. Reviews will refine this.

Notes

Top Notes
Bergamot Lemon Almond Coffee
Jasmine Vanilla Orchid
Middle Notes
Bulgarian Rose Jasmine Sambac Orange Blossom Orris Tuberose
Vanilla Tonka Bean
Base Notes
Cinnamon Vanilla Amber Musk Sandalwood Cedar Patchouli Tonka Bean Cacao Cashmere Wood Praline
Musk Patchouli Amberwood Brown Sugar

Accords

Sweet
100% White Floral
90% Vanilla
70% Warm Spicy
70% Powdery
50%
Vanilla
100% Sweet
90% Gourmand
80% Amber
70% Woody
50% Warm Spicy
40%

Good Girl feels sweet, white floral and vanilla, while Vanilla | 28 feels Creamy vanilla and brown sugar wrapped in warm amber woods, tonka and soft musk.